The first holiday season may be more joyous for new parents as opposed to the experience of a little one who is familiarizing themselves with their new world. However, gifting them keepsakes they can look back on will give them a sense of being loved, once they're old enough to appreciate the magic of Christmas! We have found adorable gifts for them before their lists are loaded with battery-operated toys and ponies!


You submitted your best ideas and helped vote the best to the top. Here they are, starting with the very best!


Crowdsourced Contest Results

Hallmark Keepsake Christmas Ornament 2018 Year Dated Baby's...
View Details

ljrrtt says:

"Not only are rattles something every baby can enjoy, it's also dated so you can keep it and later relive memories for nostalgia. "

Rudolph The Red-Nosed Reindeer Baby's First Christmas Plush...
View Details

hoboyle0514 says:

"Who doesn't love Rudolph? This iconic loveable creature not only commemorates baby's first Christmas but can also be a new best friend for baby for years to come!"

New Mommy Mama Bear Ornament 2019 Cute First Christmas New...
View Details

mjs071 says:

"Sure, it’s the baby’s first Christmas, but don’t forget there’s a new Mama Bear in town, too. With all the gifts you’ll get for that new bundle of joy, it’s nice to receive something to commemorate becoming a Mom for the first time. This ornament is the perfect gift!"

KIDS PREFERRED Rudolph The Red-Nosed Reindeer On The Go...
View Details

my4angels72 says:

"The perfect gift for your little one's first Christmas. Rudolph is not only super cute, but he sings Rudolph the Red Nosed Reindeer, he has a light up nose, he makes different sounds such as crinkles, squeaks and rattles and he also has a teething ring! "

Fisher-Price Little People Nativity
View Details

lnhindman says:

"Super cute, makes a great decoration, and so fun for babies and toddlers to play with! A Christmas classic."

Babys First Christmas Stocking; Baby Boy Stocking with...
View Details

deannamartashley says:

"Stockings are traditional and I think it would be a perfect gift for a baby. This one comes with a little monkey in it too and a picture holder. "